xtspode
Elio Addict
in the case where you need a concealed weapon, it doesn't matter how much it kicks, or how noisy it is without ear plugs, you are still going to pull the trigger. If you have a nice comfortable full frame pistol, you will not have it when you need it. The most important thing is to have one with you when you need it. I have a friend that carries a 45 double barrel derringer. It is hell to shoot, but he carries it. I have another friend that carries a 22 Mag revolver. They both have them with them all the time. The guy with the 22 mag revolver has 6 shots and the 22 mag is pretty serious, and it is really noisy with a 7/8 inch barrel. I wouldn't want it in Afghanistan, but I would like it in LA. The 45 derringer has 2 before you reload, but will leave a mark if you hit someone with it.No doubt the 357 packs a punch. I enjoy shooting my Ruger SP101, but even with that, I can only shoot ~50 rounds of 357. I can't imagine shooting the LCR in 357.
The debate will rage on and on with every opinion imaginable. The first thing though is you have to have it with you to do you any good. Whatever you carry will work infinity better than the one you left in the safe.